Loadingā¦
8
My book club hated that I didn't connect with the assigned memoir
In my experience, our group often picks emotional memoirs for deep talks. I read the latest one but thought it was too dramatic and not easy to relate to. When I shared this, everyone was shocked and said the book was honest. I feel we should pick books that let us have different opinions, not just sad stories. Take this with a grain of salt, but that's my view.
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
violal546mo ago
You thought the book was too dramatic... but everyone called it honest. That's a pretty big gap right there. Sounds like they just wanted you to feel the same way they did.
9
thompson.blair6mo ago
Last week's book club choice was that memoir about addiction. I found it so dramatic, especially the part where he loses his job. But everyone else said it was honest and real. That gap between what I felt and what they said is shocking. It feels like the group pushes for one shared feeling instead of real talk. We need books that let us disagree and learn from each other.
8
the_nathan6mo ago
The group picks emotional books because they lead to honest talks, but honest writing doesn't always mean it's easy to connect with. A memoir can feel true to the author's life while still coming across as dramatic or specific to an experience you just don't share. It's fair to want a wider range of books that spark debate instead of just agreement on how moving something was.
8