Question about using a random object generator for a story idea
I was stuck on a sci-fi plot and grabbed a random object generator online, setting it to give me three things. It spit out 'a broken compass, a jar of fireflies, and a tax form from 1982'. I tried to force them into a space opera, but the story kept turning into a quiet, sad tale about a person sorting through a dead parent's stuff. The unexpected result was a much better, more personal story than the big one I planned. Has anyone else had a prompt tool completely change the genre you were aiming for?
Yeah, that happens all the time. The tools just give you a starting point, but your own brain takes it somewhere real. The best ideas usually come from that unexpected turn.
Your comment about "your own brain takes it somewhere real" is exactly right. A buddy of mine was trying to write a thriller and used a generator for a detective's sidekick. It gave him "a retired beekeeper with a bad knee." He got SO frustrated because every time he tried to write a tense chase scene, his character would just hobble away from danger. So he finally gave up and wrote a story about that beekeeper solving a mystery by watching what the bees were doing in his backyard. It turned into this whole thing about neighborhood gossip and forgotten clues in a park. He submitted it to a small press and it actually got published in a collection about quirky detectives. The whole space opera he had planned? Never finished it.