It took me 3 hours to find a working guestbook on a GeoCities page from 1999
I got hooked on old web rings last month and ended up on a fan page for a local roller rink in Akron that hasn't been touched since 1999, and the guestbook link kept sending me to a 404. I ended up digging through the Wayback Machine for 3 hours just to read what people wrote in it, and half the entries were just "cool page, check mine out" with dead links. Does anyone else go down these rabbit holes or is it just me who wastes a whole evening on one broken link?
Three hours on a dead guestbook is a lot but I get it. Those old web rings pull you in because every link leads to another page someone built by hand in their basement. The dead links are half the fun, you never know what still works. Reading "cool page check mine out" from 1999 hits different when you know those people are probably 40 now with kids. I've lost whole nights on the Wayback Machine doing the same thing, no regrets.