PSA: I spent 2 years matching paint by eye at my shop, and a $12 color deck proved me wrong
I used to think the fan decks were for amateurs and that a real pro just eyeballs a color after 10-plus years in the trade. Two years ago I was repainting a kitchen in Evanston and the client came back after the first coat and asked why the wall looked green next to her cream cabinets. I had mixed the color in that room under my halogen work light instead of checking it in daylight, and it turned out to be three shades off from the sample she picked. That was my moment. I got a cheap color deck with the little punch-out windows and started holding it up against the cabinet door, the trim, and the wall before I ever opened a can. The window trick showed me that my eye was guessing based on memory, not measurement, and I had been doing it that way for a long time. Now I check every match twice, once inside and once by the front window, and I have not had a redo in about 14 months. Curious if the old guys here still trust their eye over a deck, or if everyone has a story like this one.