Vent: a ramp guy at DFW asked why I test a VHF comm the same way each time, and it got under my skin
Last week I was doing a ramp check on a comm radio at DFW and a young guy from the ground crew stopped and asked why I always key the mic and listen to the sidetone first. I told him it is just how I was trained, and he shrugged and moved on. That night I could not shake it, because the answer was basically "because someone in 2011 showed me that way." So I pulled the manual and tracked my last 12 squawks, and 4 of them were things I would have caught faster by checking the antenna coupler first. He was not trying to school me, he was just curious, and that made it land harder. Now I want a second opinion: what is your actual first step on a weak comm, and why?
So the guy asked a question, you didn't have a good answer, and now you're tearing apart your whole process over it? That seems like a lot. Four out of twelve squawks isn't nothing, sure, but it's not like you were missing a fuel leak or a flight control issue. A weak comm is a weak comm, and you still found the problem every time. Half of this job is just doing things the same way so you don't skip a step when you're tired or rushed. I've seen guys chase the fancy new method and forget the basics. Curious kid on the ramp doesn't mean your training was wrong.